Former England captain Ben Stokes and Gus Atkinson were involved in an incident in a London nightclub. England men's players have been advised to avoid drinking alcohol on the day before and the day after matches, under new behaviour guidelines.

A midnight curfew was introduced following an Ashes tour blighted by off-field problems, but ambiguities around the curfew were a factor in the nightclub controversy involving Ben Stokes and Gus Atkinson. In the aftermath of that incident, England players were issued new guidance, as reported by the Telegraph, external.

The updated policy confirms the midnight curfew is in place on every day of a series at home or on tour. It also recommends that no alcohol be consumed on the day immediately before, during or the day immediately after a match. If, for example, a Test runs the full five days, the recommendation extends to the following day.

The head coach and director of cricket, in this instance Brendon McCullum and Rob Key respectively, have the discretion to relax the recommendations when they see fit. That way, the hierarchy can allow players the freedom to celebrate a win or keep with traditions such as an end-of-series drink with the opposition at the conclusion of an Ashes series.

Players were allowed to drink immediately after the third Test against New Zealand at Trent Bridge, to mark Stokes' international retirement. The recommendations apply only to players, rather than staff. If players do choose to drink in the period before, during or after matches, it should not be in public. They have also been strongly discouraged from drinking in private, in order to aid preparation, recovery and professionalism.

The guidelines apply only to the England senior men's teams. All other England teams - the women, Lions and age-group teams - have their own rules. Regarding the curfew, there are periods when players would naturally leave the England camp, either because there is a long gap between matches or they have been released to their counties. It has been confirmed the curfew still applies in these circumstances, subject to the discretion of the management.

'Conversation needed over cricket drinking culture' Stokes and drinking give England another headache. Booze, beach, beaten - how England lost the Ashes. The curfew was first introduced to the England men's white-ball teams in January for their tour of Sri Lanka and the T20 World Cup that followed. It came after Harry Brook was punched by a nightclub bouncer in Wellington, with Jacob Bethell and Josh Tongue present, and following Ben Duckett being filmed, apparently drunk, on England's mid-Ashes holiday in Noosa.

In the build-up to the summer, Key confirmed the curfew remained in place. However, after England won the first Test against New Zealand at Lord's, Stokes and Atkinson were at a London nightclub into the early hours of the following day. They were present when a member of England security staff was struck by a Saracens rugby player. Stokes and Atkinson were made unavailable for the second Test, pending an investigation into the incident.

In the aftermath, Key said Atkinson was not aware that the curfew was in place. Key also suggested a total alcohol ban, which has not come to pass. Stokes and Atkinson were eventually cleared of violent conduct but were instead found to have breached "specific contractual obligations".

As the pair were once again made available for the third Test, McCullum admitted to ambiguity over the terms of the curfew and said it would be clarified so players are left with no confusion over behavioural expectations.

Now, in addition to the clarification over the terms of the curfew and the recommendations over when they should drink, players also must inform team management or security if they are out of the hotel after 22:00. Players also cannot appear under the influence of alcohol in public, or post on social media about alcohol-related activities.

The England men's team, drinking, and what to do about it is the issue that refuses to go away. There is a much broader debate to be had about cricket's relationship with alcohol. It can be argued that, as a professional sport, it is years behind others. Looking at cricket as a whole – at all levels and in a lot of countries where the game is popular – alcohol is a strong presence. In that sense, the England men's team are not unique, but they are of the highest profile and their indiscretions have been public.

The answer is hardly straightforward. England can't be seen to be doing nothing, but any regulations they do bring in come with pitfalls. The hierarchy will want to be seen as enforcing standards, without appearing draconian. Even these new regulations come with a degree of ambiguity. They are recommendations, rather than rules – players can still drink whenever they like, if they please. The advice can also be relaxed as the management see fit.

From now on, England will probably face regular questions as to what merits a beer, and what does not. It has been confirmed this advice applies only to the senior England men's team. Other England teams have their own guidance, so we could have a situation where the senior men are under alcohol guidance, but the England women, Lions and age-group teams are not.

There is also the probability of an England player not being allowed out past midnight even if he has returned home during a gap in a series. At a time when the positions of the England management are again under scrutiny, one wonders how this advice fits in with Brendon McCullum's "informal" environment.

'Sack him' - Stokes on potential retirement rule breach Stokes created moments and the moments are no more. Get cricket news sent straight to your phone.